| ROUND | R1 | R2 | R3 | R4 | R5 | QF | SF | F | ||||||
| r1 | R | r2 | R | r3 | R | r4 | R | r5 | R | qf | R | |||
| Season archive |
| Friday, 2 December 2011 | ||||||
| r2 | Fleetwood Town | 2-2 | Yeovil Town | |||
| Saturday, 3 December 2011 | ||||||
| r2 | Brentford | 0-1 | Wrexham | |||
| r2 | Gateshead | 1-2 | Tamworth | |||
| r2 | Sheffield United | 3-2 | Torquay United | |||
| r2 | Shrewsbury Town | 2-1 | Rotherham United | |||
| r2 | Sheffield Wednesday | 1-0 | Aldershot Town | |||
| r2 | Barnet | 1-3 | Milton Keynes Dons | |||
| r2 | Bradford City | 3-1 | AFC Wimbledon | |||
| r2 | Charlton Athletic | 2-0 | Carlisle United | |||
| r2 | Crawley Town | 5-0 | Redbridge | |||
| r2 | Dagenham & Redbridge | 1-1 | Walsall | |||
| r2 | Leyton Orient | 0-1 | Gillingham | |||
| r2 | Luton Town | 2-4 | Cheltenham Town | |||
| r2 | Salisbury | 0-0 | Grimsby Town | |||
| r2 | Southend United | 1-1 | Oldham Athletic | |||
| r2 | Stourbridge | 0-3 | Stevenage | |||
| r2 | Chelmsford City | 1-1 | Macclesfield FC | |||
| r2 | Colchester United | 0-1 | Swindon Town | |||
| Sunday, 4 December 2011 | ||||||
| r2 | AFC Totton | 1-6 | Bristol Rovers | |||
| r2 | Sutton United | 0-2 | Notts County | |||
| Tuesday, 13 December 2011 | ||||||
| r2R | Oldham Athletic | 1-0 | Southend United | |||
| r2R | Walsall | 0-0 | Dagenham & Redbridge | aet, p2-3 | ||
| r2R | Grimsby Town | 2-3 | Salisbury | aet | ||
| r2R | Yeovil Town | 0-2 | Fleetwood Town | |||
| Wednesday, 14 December 2011 | ||||||
| r2R | Macclesfield FC | 1-0 | Chelmsford City | |||
| 4 | +2 | Ched EVANS (Sheffield United) |
| 3 | +3 | Matt TUBBS (Crawley Town, 2p) |
| +1 | Lewis GRABBAN (Rotherham United, 2p) | |
| +1 | Jon NURSE (Dagenham & Redbridge) | |
| 2 | +1 | Dan FITCHETT (Salisbury) |
| +1 | Ed UPSON (Yeovil Town) | |
| +2 | Aaron O'CONNOR (Luton Town) | |
| +2 | Chris BEARDSLEY (Stevenage) | |
| +2 | Robert DUFFY (Grimsby Town) | |
| +1 | Mustapha CARAYOL (Bristol Rovers) | |
| Brian WOODALL (Dagenham & Redbridge) | ||
| +1 | Danny STEVENS (Torquay United) | |
| +2 | Jeff HUGHES (Notts County) | |
| +2 | Eliot RICHARDS (Bristol Rovers) | |
| +1 | Darryl DUFFY (Cheltenham Town, 1p) | |
| Karl HAWLEY (Notts County) | ||
| +1 | Jamie VARDY (Fleetwood Town) | |
| +1 | Kyle PATTERSON (Tamworth) | |
| +1 | Rene HOWE (Torquay United) | |
| +1 | Curtis WESTON (Gillingham) | |
| +1 | Daniel POWELL (Milton Keynes Dons) | |
| Dave RAINFORD (Chelmsford City, 1p) | ||
| Dean BOWDITCH (Milton Keynes Dons) | ||
| Lloyd JAMES (Colchester United) | ||
| Josh COULSON (Cambridge United) | ||
| +1 | Carl TREMARCO (Macclesfield FC) | |
| Andy MORRELL (Wrexham) |